The Difference Between Shred-All vs. Selective Shredding

The Difference Between Shred-All vs. Selective Shredding

Need help choosing?

Find the Right Shredder

Answer a few quick questions and get pointed toward the shredder type that fits your documents, volume, and security needs.

Find the Right Shredder Shop High-Security Shredders

Every business and company must keep documents tracking various data, such as financial records or employee data. However, every document has an expiration date. After that, it’s no longer necessary to store the information. At that point, you can shred the documents according to two policies: shred-all or selective shredding. To make that choice, you must know the difference between shred-all and selective shredding.

Shred-All Policies

Shred-all policies are the simplest policies to uphold and follow for your business. Simply put, these policies focus on shredding all documents the moment their expiration dates hit. You send them to the shredder as soon as you no longer need to legally carry them. However, this method requires a heavy-duty commercial paper shredder, as you need to get rid of a lot of paper at once.

Saving Space

This policy is very useful because it takes very little training to have employees check the dates of files and shred them if they’re past their dates. Additionally, it means you’re constantly cleaning out all the documents you don’t need, saving space and freeing it up for other documents.

Selective Shredding Policies

Selective shredding focuses on only shredding certain documentation. What each company shreds depends on the policies they create and enforce for their own data. This requires more organization, as someone needs to go through the data to determine if the company should shred it.

Keeping Sensitive Data

The main benefit of this system is keeping sensitive data or important information for longer than legally necessary. Some data is useful far after the date of expiration. It may be important for the company years later. Sorting though the data can help you preserve the things you may need in the future.

Which To Choose

It’s hard to say that one is better than the other, as they both come with benefits and issues. Larger companies will likely benefit from selective shredding, while small businesses can save workers and space by using shred-all policies. However, you’ll likely need to weigh the risks of keeping information around versus how useful it may be in the future for your field and company.

Learning the difference between shred-all policies and selective shredding can help your company. Choosing the right one can protect your data and make it easier for your employees in the long run. It all depends on what you need for your documents.

Recommended next step

Recommended products for this topic

These product suggestions are selected from the category that best matches this article topic, so readers can move from research to comparison without changing the article content.

K-9 Deskside DOD High-Security Paper Shredder K-9 $1,655.00 Security: DOD Level 6 / P-7 Cross CutSheet capacity: Up to 6 sheetsShred size: 0.8 x 5 mmWaste: 10 Gal View product → M-9 Desktop DOD High-Security Paper Shredder M-9 $3,100.00 Security: DOD Level 6 / P-7 Cross CutSheet capacity: Up to 7 sheetsShred size: 1mm x 4mmWaste: 6 Gal View product → SS-9 DOD Deskside High Security Paper Shredder SS-9 $2,750.00 Security: DOD Level 6 / P-7 Cross CutSheet capacity: Up to 8 sheetsShred size: 1/32" x 3/16" Waste: 15 Gal View product →

Choose faster

Choose the right shredder path

Not sure what fits?

Answer a few questions and narrow your choices by security level, volume, and media type.

Take the shredder finder quiz
Handling sensitive documents?

Start with high-security shredders for confidential, regulated, government, or classified paper.

Compare high-security shredders
Destroying drives or media?

Move beyond paper shredding to physical destruction options for hard drives and media workflows.

Shop hard drive and media destruction
High office volume?

Compare machines built around larger workloads, shared teams, higher capacity, and heavier daily use.

View high-volume options
Working from home or a small office?

Start with compact options built for everyday paperwork, smaller teams, and easier office placement.

Shop home office shredders
Need maintenance supplies?

Keep shredders protected with oil, bags, and supplies that support long-term performance.

Shop shredder supplies

Why buy from Capital Shredder

Helpful buying support after the guide

Free contiguous U.S. shipping

Standard shipping is available within the contiguous U.S. for qualifying orders.

Lease options available

Customers can review purchase pricing and available lease options with approved lease.

Expert shredder guidance

Get help matching security level, sheet capacity, media type, and workload to the right machine.

Take the Shredder Finder Request Expert Help

Ready to choose?

Choose the right shredder with confidence

Get matched with the right security level, sheet capacity, media type, and workload before you compare models or request a recommendation.

Take the Shredder Finder Find the Right Shredder Request Expert Help

4 Tips for Dealing With a Jammed Paper Shredder

The Difference Between Commercial and Home Paper Shredders